PDA

View Full Version : Medea G-Raid



derekh
18-11-2004, 08:58 PM
Anyone done testing with the Medea G-Raid? www.medea.com

My local apple store was recommending against the spec on high end's website with the internal scsi drive and I'm looking for a middle-cost solution.

tharding
18-11-2004, 11:28 PM
What reason did they give for recommending against it?

samsc
18-11-2004, 11:56 PM
i think hugh has one of these?

hugh and flyingpig.com

samsc
18-11-2004, 11:58 PM
no. i was wrong hugh has a scsi one.

the g-raid uses standard ata/ide drives.
these are not good for use with catalyst.

standard ide drives have very poor access times.
very poor.

catalyst has different requirements from video editing.
your local apple dealer will not understand these requirements.

samsc
19-11-2004, 11:41 AM
Anyone done testing with the Medea G-Raid? www.medea.com

My local apple store was recommending against the spec on high end's website with the internal scsi drive and I'm looking for a middle-cost solution.

im interested in the reason you apple store gave too.

derekh
19-11-2004, 04:34 PM
the tekserve guy's objection was more style than substance - older technology - SCSI - together with brand new technology - G5

most other customers who want similar access times are going to fibrechannel

what about just a second drive that is a 10k or 15k serial ATA?

samsc
19-11-2004, 06:55 PM
the tekserve guy's objection was more style than substance - older technology - SCSI - together with brand new technology - G5

most other customers who want similar access times are going to fibrechannel

what about just a second drive that is a 10k or 15k serial ATA?

the latest scsi drives are latest technology.
and they are much faster than ide/ata drives.

fibrechannel is a total unknown in this market- its even more specialised and more expensive.
apple's fibre channel X-Raids start at 6000$. i think martin in norway had one on test from apple - i wonder how he got on.
I dont know of a cheaper solution - but i never looked.

---
All current ata drives - except the raptor drives from western digital run at 7200rpm.
the raptors run at 10000rpm, but only go up to 75gb.
The latest generation of scsi drives, go up to 300gb at 15000 and 10000rpm.
Raptor drives work pretty well with catalyst - but 75gb is not enough for a lot of people for a content drive.